{
 "title": "Otso 1.1 hindcast on live inputs, September 2026",
 "window": "2026-09-01 .. 2026-09-20 (20 start days, 00 UTC runs, leads 12 .. 120 h)",
 "truth": "CAMS analysis at the valid time (00 and 12 UTC)",
 "statistic": "RMSE of the ensemble mean, cosine-latitude weighted, mean over the 20 days, ug m-3",
 "systems": {
  "otso": "Otso 1.1 with GFAS fires (injh)",
  "otso_no_fires": "Otso 1.1 without fires",
  "cams_forecast": "CAMS operational forecast of the same 00 UTC run (leads 24 and 120 h fetched)",
  "persistence": "the 00 UTC analysis kept unchanged"
 },
 "fire_cells": "0.4 deg cells with FRP > 0.3 W m-2 on at least one day of the window (5.7 % of the grid)",
 "paper_2022": {
  "note": "Same protocol on 1 May - 30 Nov 2022 (214 days, archived HRES, GFAS v1.2 with mami, 2022 emissions), RMSE all cells",
  "leads_h": [
   12,
   24,
   48,
   72,
   120
  ],
  "otso": [
   4.01,
   5.12,
   5.53,
   5.8,
   6.33
  ],
  "cams_forecast": [
   2.74,
   4.61,
   5.74,
   6.53,
   7.71
  ],
  "persistence": [
   7.29,
   7.54,
   8.79,
   9.29,
   9.6
  ]
 },
 "rows": [
  {
   "lead_h": 12,
   "rmse_all": {
    "otso": 8.53,
    "otso_no_fires": 10.37,
    "cams_forecast": null,
    "persistence": 11.37
   },
   "rmse_land": {
    "otso": 14.42,
    "otso_no_fires": 18.07,
    "cams_forecast": null,
    "persistence": 20.07
   },
   "rmse_fire_cells": {
    "otso": 23.55,
    "otso_no_fires": 32.0,
    "cams_forecast": null
   },
   "bias_fire_cells": {
    "otso": 0.9,
    "otso_no_fires": -1.95
   },
   "bias_land": {
    "otso": 0.29,
    "otso_no_fires": -0.42
   },
   "days": 20
  },
  {
   "lead_h": 24,
   "rmse_all": {
    "otso": 8.71,
    "otso_no_fires": 9.09,
    "cams_forecast": 5.43,
    "persistence": 10.13
   },
   "rmse_land": {
    "otso": 14.47,
    "otso_no_fires": 15.18,
    "cams_forecast": 9.16,
    "persistence": 17.21
   },
   "rmse_fire_cells": {
    "otso": 14.45,
    "otso_no_fires": 16.74,
    "cams_forecast": 11.56
   },
   "bias_fire_cells": {
    "otso": 2.04,
    "otso_no_fires": -2.2
   },
   "bias_land": {
    "otso": 0.18,
    "otso_no_fires": -0.94
   },
   "days": 20
  },
  {
   "lead_h": 36,
   "rmse_all": {
    "otso": 10.22,
    "otso_no_fires": 11.75,
    "cams_forecast": null,
    "persistence": 13.36
   },
   "rmse_land": {
    "otso": 17.04,
    "otso_no_fires": 20.05,
    "cams_forecast": null,
    "persistence": 23.12
   },
   "rmse_fire_cells": {
    "otso": 27.63,
    "otso_no_fires": 34.96,
    "cams_forecast": null
   },
   "bias_fire_cells": {
    "otso": 0.93,
    "otso_no_fires": -2.71
   },
   "bias_land": {
    "otso": 0.16,
    "otso_no_fires": -0.8
   },
   "days": 20
  },
  {
   "lead_h": 48,
   "rmse_all": {
    "otso": 9.43,
    "otso_no_fires": 9.86,
    "cams_forecast": null,
    "persistence": 11.77
   },
   "rmse_land": {
    "otso": 15.63,
    "otso_no_fires": 16.35,
    "cams_forecast": null,
    "persistence": 19.9
   },
   "rmse_fire_cells": {
    "otso": 16.33,
    "otso_no_fires": 18.69,
    "cams_forecast": null
   },
   "bias_fire_cells": {
    "otso": 1.8,
    "otso_no_fires": -2.75
   },
   "bias_land": {
    "otso": 0.08,
    "otso_no_fires": -1.13
   },
   "days": 20
  },
  {
   "lead_h": 60,
   "rmse_all": {
    "otso": 11.08,
    "otso_no_fires": 12.19,
    "cams_forecast": null,
    "persistence": 13.95
   },
   "rmse_land": {
    "otso": 18.54,
    "otso_no_fires": 20.61,
    "cams_forecast": null,
    "persistence": 24.0
   },
   "rmse_fire_cells": {
    "otso": 30.6,
    "otso_no_fires": 35.86,
    "cams_forecast": null
   },
   "bias_fire_cells": {
    "otso": 0.38,
    "otso_no_fires": -2.98
   },
   "bias_land": {
    "otso": -0.05,
    "otso_no_fires": -1.02
   },
   "days": 20
  },
  {
   "lead_h": 72,
   "rmse_all": {
    "otso": 9.85,
    "otso_no_fires": 10.3,
    "cams_forecast": null,
    "persistence": 12.26
   },
   "rmse_land": {
    "otso": 16.28,
    "otso_no_fires": 17.0,
    "cams_forecast": null,
    "persistence": 20.68
   },
   "rmse_fire_cells": {
    "otso": 17.33,
    "otso_no_fires": 19.83,
    "cams_forecast": null
   },
   "bias_fire_cells": {
    "otso": 1.32,
    "otso_no_fires": -2.95
   },
   "bias_land": {
    "otso": -0.03,
    "otso_no_fires": -1.23
   },
   "days": 20
  },
  {
   "lead_h": 84,
   "rmse_all": {
    "otso": 11.01,
    "otso_no_fires": 11.96,
    "cams_forecast": null,
    "persistence": 13.8
   },
   "rmse_land": {
    "otso": 18.28,
    "otso_no_fires": 20.02,
    "cams_forecast": null,
    "persistence": 23.59
   },
   "rmse_fire_cells": {
    "otso": 30.17,
    "otso_no_fires": 34.77,
    "cams_forecast": null
   },
   "bias_fire_cells": {
    "otso": 0.33,
    "otso_no_fires": -2.98
   },
   "bias_land": {
    "otso": 0.0,
    "otso_no_fires": -0.99
   },
   "days": 20
  },
  {
   "lead_h": 96,
   "rmse_all": {
    "otso": 9.76,
    "otso_no_fires": 10.17,
    "cams_forecast": null,
    "persistence": 12.1
   },
   "rmse_land": {
    "otso": 16.17,
    "otso_no_fires": 16.78,
    "cams_forecast": null,
    "persistence": 20.29
   },
   "rmse_fire_cells": {
    "otso": 17.22,
    "otso_no_fires": 19.57,
    "cams_forecast": null
   },
   "bias_fire_cells": {
    "otso": 1.27,
    "otso_no_fires": -2.91
   },
   "bias_land": {
    "otso": 0.05,
    "otso_no_fires": -1.16
   },
   "days": 20
  },
  {
   "lead_h": 108,
   "rmse_all": {
    "otso": 10.85,
    "otso_no_fires": 11.71,
    "cams_forecast": null,
    "persistence": 13.67
   },
   "rmse_land": {
    "otso": 18.01,
    "otso_no_fires": 19.55,
    "cams_forecast": null,
    "persistence": 23.3
   },
   "rmse_fire_cells": {
    "otso": 30.12,
    "otso_no_fires": 34.26,
    "cams_forecast": null
   },
   "bias_fire_cells": {
    "otso": 0.25,
    "otso_no_fires": -2.88
   },
   "bias_land": {
    "otso": 0.1,
    "otso_no_fires": -0.86
   },
   "days": 20
  },
  {
   "lead_h": 120,
   "rmse_all": {
    "otso": 9.62,
    "otso_no_fires": 10.0,
    "cams_forecast": 8.93,
    "persistence": 12.02
   },
   "rmse_land": {
    "otso": 16.06,
    "otso_no_fires": 16.6,
    "cams_forecast": 14.99,
    "persistence": 20.16
   },
   "rmse_fire_cells": {
    "otso": 17.44,
    "otso_no_fires": 19.57,
    "cams_forecast": 18.15
   },
   "bias_fire_cells": {
    "otso": 1.14,
    "otso_no_fires": -3.08
   },
   "bias_land": {
    "otso": 0.25,
    "otso_no_fires": -0.95
   },
   "days": 20
  }
 ],
 "notes": [
  "Live inputs: CAMS analysis 00 UTC; IFS open data at 0.25 deg (the paper used the archived HRES); GFAS v1.4.2 with injh instead of mami (v1.4.2 also detects about twice as many fire cells); anthropogenic emissions of the same month of 2022.",
  "September 2026 is a harder period than the 2022 test: the persistence error is 25-55 % larger. Relative to persistence, Otso is weaker than in 2022 (0.75 vs 0.55 of the persistence error at 12 h; 0.80 vs 0.66 at 120 h) while the CAMS forecast is stronger: the CAMS system changed since 2022 and Otso has not been retrained on its new analyses.",
  "The CAMS forecast is produced by the same model that produces the analysis used as truth, which favours it at short leads."
 ]
}